C039 - Fig. 3d: varying the radial spectator-mode spectrum (via an added quadrupole) shows F(|Ps...
Verdict: data_unavailable (data_unavailable)
Location: Fig. 3d
Type / expected artifact: plot / figure (errors_bit_flip.pdf)
Claim: Fig. 3d: varying the radial spectator-mode spectrum (via an added quadrupole) shows F(|Psi^->) degrades outside a narrow curvature window where spectator transitions are off-resonant.
Models: extraction claude-opus-4-8; verification gpt-5; verification_chain claude-opus-4-8 -> gpt-5; verdict_chain data_unavailable -> data_unavailable.
Limitations: data_unavailable.
Source location(s): source/main.tex:157 (Fig. 3d).
Conclusion
Fig 3d is MEASURED F(|Psi->) vs radial tilt curvature, showing a narrow clear window (paper ~5.7e7-6.1e7 V/m^2). Purely experimental data with no reproducible model; no raw data or data/code link exists (inventory.json). Cannot be reproduced -> data_unavailable. figure.png is a copy of the paper panel for reference.
Verification details
Executable rerun: run.py exited 0 in 0.402s; log verification/C039/attempts/R002/run.log.
Output excerpt:
Paper-stated narrow clear curvature window: [5.70e+07, 6.10e+07] V/m^2
Fig 3d is MEASURED F vs curvature; raw experimental data unavailable.
No reproduction possible -> data_unavailable.
wrote (no figure generated by simulation; see paper_figure.png)
Plot evidence:
Visual comparison notes: - Fig 3d plots MEASURED F(|Psi->) vs radial spectator-mode curvature (set by an added quadrupole potential), showing degradation outside a narrow clear curvature window (paper quotes ~5.7e7 to 6.1e7 V/m^2). This is purely experimental data with no underlying reproducible model; no raw data and no data/code link exist (inventory.json), so the claim cannot be reproduced. - No simulation reproduces this measured dataset; figure.png is a copy of the paper panel for reference only. - No reproduction of the measured data was possible -> data unavailable. - Round-2 verifier reran the self-contained script where present and audited the modeled quantity; no new raw paper data was available.
